Sara A Nicholas, DO

OB-GYN • Youngstown, OH

Home/Youngstown/OB-GYN/Sara A Nicholas, DO

About

Sara A Nicholas, DO, is an obstetrician and gynecologist in Youngstown, Ohio, affiliated with Mercy Health - St. Elizabeth Youngstown Hospital and Mercy Health - St. Elizabeth Boardman Hospital. Dr. Nicholas is board certified in obstetrics and gynecology and has a special interest in minimally invasive surgery.

Book appointment Call clinic Visit website

Clinic Type

OB-GYN

Address

Mercy Health - St. Elizabeth Youngstown Hospital; Mercy Health - St. Elizabeth Boardman Hospital

Phone

330-480-3033

Email

emailCompliance@BSMHealth.org

Opening Hours

Not published — contact the clinic to confirm hours.

Website

https://www.mercy.com/find-a-doctor/physicians/sara-a-nicholas/287685

Services Offered

Obstetrics and Gynecology

Team

Sara A Nicholas, Board Certified in Obstetrics and Gynecology — DO, Obstetrician/Gynecologist

Insurance & Payment

Aetna Better Health OH
Aetna Commercial & Aetna Medicare OH
Align Senior Care OH
AmeriHealth Caritas Medicaid OH
Anthem Elevance Health KY & OH
AultCare OH
Buckeye Health Plan OH
CareSource OH
Cigna OH
CIN - MHS NON-MSSP
CommuniCare Medicare Advantage OH
Devoted Health Medicare Advantage OH KY
DOL KY & OH
HealthSmart OH
Healthspring Medicare Advantage OH
Humana Military KY & OH
Humana OH
Immergrun OH
Martin's Point Health Care OH
Medicaid OH
Medical Mutual of Ohio
Medicare OH
Medicare Railroad KY & OH
Molina Medicare & Medicaid OH
Multiplan OH
NaphCare OH
Ohio BWC
Ohio Health Choice
OMC (Oscar Mgmt) OH KY SC VA
Paramount Elite Medicare Advantage OH
Payer Provider
Perennial Medicare Advantage OH
Quality Care Partners PPO OH
Sedgwick/Careworks KY OH SC VA
SummaCare OH
The Health Plan OH
United Healthcare OH
Valor Health Plan OH
Wellcare Meridian MI

Insurance, Cash, CareCredit, Credit Card

Languages Spoken

English

Social Media

Youtube Facebook Linkedin Instagram

Photos

What Patients Say

Overall sentiment across review platforms: positive

Health US News: 5/5 (37 reviews)
Mercy Health: 4.8/5 (20 reviews (from 144 ratings))
WebMD: 5.0/5 (7 reviews)
Healthgrades: 4.8/5 (38 reviews (34 written))

Patients praise

Compassionate and caring demeanor reported by many patients
Effective communication and thorough explanations of conditions and procedures
Patients frequently feel comfortable and listened to
High likelihood of recommending the doctor to friends and family

Common complaints

Reports of feeling rushed or that the physician was abrupt and rough during examinations
Concerns regarding lack of sensitivity or communication during procedures
Some patients reported physical discomfort during exams

"Sara Nicholas is the best OB I have ever been to! She always makes you feel comfortable! I have never left her office with any questions or concerns!"

— Mercy Health Patient Review

"Once Dr. was in the room, was never asked if I was comfortable or made to feel so. With her hands, she was abrupt and rough. ... Her attempt at the exam left me feeling physical pain."

— Healthgrades Patient Review

Synthesized from public review platforms as of Jul 11, 2026 — sources: [1][2][3][4].

In the News

Dr. Sara Wiswell, DO - Wooster, OH - Obstetrics and Gynecology - Request Appointment — Mar 30, 2026
Dr. Sarah Nicholas, MD - Gilbert, AZ - Radiation Oncology - Schedule Appointment — Nov 25, 2025

Information sourced from the clinic's website as of July 11, 2026. Own this clinic? Claim or correct this listing.