West Idaho Orthopedics & Sports Medicine

Orthopedic Clinic • Sun Valley, ID

Home/Sun Valley/Orthopedic Clinic/West Idaho Orthopedics & Sports Medicine

About

West Idaho Orthopedics & Sprts is a private hospital/health care provider based in Caldwell, Idaho, offering orthopedic and sports medicine services. Key details: - Services: total joint replacement, fracture care, shoulders, rotator cuff, elbows, hands/wrist, hips, knees, feet/ankle, bunion prevention/treatment, Achilles tendinitis, arthroscopy. - Specialties: orthopedic specialists and sports medicine; focuses on joints, fractures, and related musculoskeletal care. - Locations: three offices in Idaho (Caldwell; Meridian – Overland Rd). - 206 E Elm St, Caldwell, ID 83605 - 3875 E Overland Rd, Meridian, ID 83642 (two Meridian offices) - Contact: multiple phone numbers listed (main area codes 208). If you’re specifically searching for orthopedic care in Boise/Meridian or Sun Valley, this group serves the Boise metro area (Meridian) and Caldwell, and may be a fit for joint replacement, sports medicine, and general orthopedic needs in those locations.

Call clinic Visit website

Clinic Type

Orthopedic Clinic (multi-location group)

Address

3875 E Overland Rd Suite 106 Meridian, ID 83642; 1906 Fairview Ave. Suite 400 Caldwell, ID 83605; 1210 NW. 16th Street Fruitland, ID 83619

Phone

208-895-0888

Email

info@westidahoorthopedics.com

Opening Hours

Not published — contact the clinic to confirm hours.

Website

https://westidahoorthopedics.com/

Services Offered

—

Team

John Smith — MD
Michael Daines — MD
Hodaka Abe — PAC
Shane Leavitt — MD
Todd Otstotpa — MD
Davis Everton — MD

Insurance & Payment

—

Languages Spoken

—

Photos

What Patients Say

Overall sentiment across review platforms: mixed

Healthgrades: 4.14/5 (for Dr. George Nicola) (Not explicitly stated total count)
Vitals: Not explicitly stated (1 rating and review shown) (1)
Regenerative Medicine Now: 4/5 (sample review) (Not explicitly stated total count)

Patients praise

Some patients report successful outcomes with specific surgeons like Dr. Michael Daines and Dr. George Nicola
Positive bedside manner and skill recognized in individual practitioners

Common complaints

Long wait times and administrative delays in scheduling surgery
Poor communication regarding insurance coverage and surgery cancellations
Staff unhelpfulness and perceived lack of attention from providers
Frustration regarding transparency in medical costs

"They called 3 days before the surgery and cancelled the surgery. I was told that my surgeon was not compatible with my insurance/hospital and that I would have to find another surgeon. ... I felt that my time and money were wasted."

— Vitals/Healthgrades

"I highly recommend Dr Michael Daines from west Idaho orthopedics. His specialty is shoulders and he completed a shoulder fellowship at Oxford. He is extremely qualified, attentive,…"

— Nextdoor

"Would of been 5 stars if Dr. Nicola wasn't retiring and had to leave his patients with a Dr. Who doesn't seem to care or listen as well as Dr. Nicola did."

— LocalityBiz

Synthesized from public review platforms as of Jul 11, 2026 — sources: [1][2][3][4].