NY Orthopedics

Orthopedics • Staten Island, NY

Home/Staten Island/Orthopedics/NY Orthopedics

About

NY Orthopedics in Staten Island offers orthopedic and sports medicine care at 1870 Richmond Road. The practice provides arthroscopic surgery, joint replacement, spine care, and treatment for conditions including ACL tears, rotator cuff tears, labrum tears, and Tommy John surgery, along with services for knee, hip, shoulder, elbow, hand, and wrist injuries.

Call clinic Visit website

Clinic Type

Orthopedics

Address

1870 Richmond Road, Staten Island, NY 10306

Phone

(718) 285-7118

Email

—

Opening Hours

Monday: 10:00AM-4:30PM / Tuesday: 10:00AM-6:45PM / Wednesday: 8:00AM-5:00PM / Thursday: 10:00AM-5:30PM / Friday: 8:00AM-5:00PM

Website

https://newyorkorthopedics.com/locations/staten-island/

Services Offered

Orthopedics
Sports Medicine
Arthroscopic surgery
Knee and hip care
Shoulder and elbow care
Hand and wrist care
Spine care
Joint replacement
Tommy John surgery
Labrum tear treatment
ACL/Tear treatment
Rotator cuff tear treatment
Quadriceps tendon autografts
Hip/knee replacement
Knee pain treatment

Technology & Equipment

Arthroscopic surgery
Joint replacement technologies
Shoulder/rotator cuff treatment modalities

Team

Matthew (Teo) Mendez-Zfass — M.D.

Insurance & Payment

—

Languages Spoken

English

FAQs

What are the clinic hours?

Monday–Friday hours listed above.

What are the hours for Staten Island location?

Monday: 10:00AM-4:30PM / Tuesday: 10:00AM-6:45PM / Wednesday: 8:00AM-5:00PM / Thursday: 10:00AM-5:30PM / Friday: 8:00AM-5:00PM

Social Media

Twitter Facebook Linkedin Instagram

Photos

What Patients Say

Overall sentiment across review platforms: positive

Healthgrades: 4.9/5 (264)
WebMD Care: 5.0/5 (69)
WebMD Care: 4.5/5 (44)
RateMDs: 4.9/5 (33)
Healthgrades: 4.2/5 (25)

Patients praise

high level of professional expertise and knowledge
compassionate and attentive bedside manner
effective communication of treatment plans and options
conservative approach prioritizing non-surgical treatments where appropriate
helpful and professional office staff
successful outcomes for surgeries and procedures

Common complaints

occasional long wait times in office
perceived lack of attentiveness or failure to identify pain sources in some patient experiences
general patient frustration with doctors not listening to pain complaints

"Dr. McCulloch is one of the best! Great bedside manner, took all the time I needed to make me understand everything that needed to be treated. Great results. Great with documentation, and one of the best staff I've ever dealt with."

— New York Sports & Joints patient testimonial

"Kudos to the staff at Dr Montalbano’s office! They are the most professional and at the same time, the most heartwarming group of Professionals by far. A huge thank you to Dr. MONTALBANO for diagnosing my hip injury and treating it with an overwhelming result!"

— RateMDs review for Dr. Gregory Montalbano

"Spent almost 2 hours waiting and had to leave without seeing the doctor."

— RateMDs review for Dr. John C. L'Insalata

Synthesized from public review platforms as of Jul 11, 2026 — sources: [1][2][3][4].