Froedtert South

Orthopedic Surgery • Menasha, WI • Since 1903

Home/Menasha/Orthopedic Surgery/Froedtert South

About

Orthopedic Care at Froedtert South (covering the Menasha area context) - Froedtert South is a nonprofit regional healthcare system serving southeastern Wisconsin and northern Illinois for over 100 years, with orthopedic services among its offerings. - Orthopedic services likely encompass general orthopedics, spine, joint replacement, and related musculoskeletal care, aligned with Froedtert South’s broader services (e.g., robotic-assisted surgery, physical/occupational therapy, and related specialties). - Locations in the area include offices in Kenosha and Pleasant Prairie, with the HQ at Kenosha (note: Meneasha-specific facility details aren’t explicitly listed in the provided highlights). If you’re specifically seeking Menasha-area orthopedic care, the page does not clearly confirm a Menasha facility; the system’s primary Michigan/IL-WI footprint is in Kenosha and Pleasant Prairie. Consider contacting Froedtert South directly or checking the Froedtert South site for the nearest orthopedic clinic location and appointment options.

Book appointment Call clinic Visit website Get directions

Clinic Type

Orthopedic Surgery

Address

9697 St. Catherine's Drive, Pleasant Prairie, WI 53158

Phone

262.656.3590

Email

billing@froedtertsouth.com

Opening Hours

Orthopedic Walk-In Urgent Care: Monday–Thursday 8:00 AM–3:30 PM; Friday 8:00 AM–2:30 PM at Prairie Ridge Clinic

Website

https://www.froedtertsouth.com/services/orthopedic-care-services/

Services Offered

Orthopedic Care Services
Orthopedic Clinic
Orthopedic Surgery
Orthopedic Walk-In Urgent Care
Shoulder and Elbow Specialist
Foot and Ankle Surgery
Total Joint Replacement
Minimally Invasive Outpatient Surgeries
Podiatry (Foot and Ankle)
Neurosurgery (spine related)
Joint replacement consultations
Second opinions on total joint replacements

Technology & Equipment

state-of-the-art surgical equipment
minimally invasive techniques
outpatient surgeries

Team

Mohammad Al Sawaf, M.D. — Orthopedic Surgeon
Jonathan Ben-Zev, M. — Orthopedic Surgeon
Alan Gegenheimer — D.O.
Syed K. Mehdi — M.D.
Anthony Zacharias — M.D.
Altamash Iftikhar — D.O.
Ryan Holmbeck — D.P.M.
Antonio Montemurro — D.P.M.

Insurance & Payment

—

Languages Spoken

—

FAQs

What orthopedic services are offered?

Orthopedic care, joint replacement, minimally invasive outpatient surgeries, shoulder and elbow, foot and ankle, spine-related neurosurgery, and podiatry.

Where is Froedtert South Orthopedic Clinic located?

9697 St. Catherine's Drive, Pleasant Prairie, WI 53158.

What are the hours for Orthopedic Walk-In Urgent Care?

Monday through Thursday: 8:00 AM to 3:30 PM | Friday 8:00 AM to 2:30 PM

Social Media

Youtube

Photos

What Patients Say

Overall sentiment across review platforms: mixed

US News (Froedtert South-Kenosha Medical Center - Orthopedic Surgeons listing): Patient ratings shown on page include examples like 5/5 and 4/5 for orthopedic-related doctor entries, but no single aggregate rating for “Orthopedic Care Services - Froedtert South Menasha” is provided in the sources (The page shows review counts for individual doctors (e.g., “22 Reviews,” “70 Reviews,” “434 Reviews,” “673 Reviews,” etc.))
Vitals (Froedtert South Bone And Joint Center: Pleasant Prairie, WI): Physician ratings shown include values like 4.6 and 4.3 (No explicit review count totals for the practice are shown in the provided snippet; it states “Be first to leave a review”)
WebMD (Froedtert South Bone And Joint Center: Pleasant Prairie, WI): The provided snippet does not display an overall practice rating; it indicates a “Froedtert South Bone And Joint Center Rating” area and that users should write a review (The snippet does not give a usable total; it references a count in parentheses “(46)” for a physician listing)

Patients praise

Orthopedic surgeons are presented as “Patients Top Choice” on US News’s orthopedic surgeons listing page for the Froedtert South-Kenosha Medical Center campus.
Some patient-experience domains appear relatively strong on a hospital patient-experience comparison page (e.g., doctors and nurses communicating well, and room/bathroom cleanliness percentages) for FROEDTERT SOUTH - KENOSHA MEDICAL CENTER.

Common complaints

Patient reviews available in the sources include complaints about overcharging/high bills for an orthopedic/sports medicine clinic experience.
There are reports of administrative/operational issues such as arriving and not having anyone at the front desk and denial of care later in the day (then appointment next morning) from an orthopedic/sports medicine clinic review source.

"“Of all the hospitals in Kenosha, the overcharges at this one may be the most egregious. Case in point: a simple swab test ...”"

— Yelp: FROEDTERT SOUTH - KENOSHA (reviews snippet)

"“Was referred by my doctor to come here for quick all inclusive care for broken bones. Arrived at 5pm and no one was at the front desk… Denied care that evening and made an appointment for the next morning…”"

— Birdeye: Froedtert Sports Medicine Center Ortho Now Clinic (review snippet)

"“Patients who reported that their doctors communicated well” (80% for this hospital) and “patients who reported that their nurses communicated well” (81% for this hospital) are shown on the patient-experience comparison page for FROEDTERT SOUTH - KENOSHA MEDICAL CENTER."

— healthcarecomps.com: patient experiences at FROEDTERT SOUTH - KENOSHA MEDICAL CENTER

Synthesized from public review platforms as of Jul 11, 2026 — sources: [1][2][3][4].

In the News

Laura Thometz Puglessi, PA, NCCPA | Froedtert & the Medical College of Wisconsin — Oct 21, 2025
Katherine S. Cox, PA-C | Froedtert & the Medical College of Wisconsin — Oct 3, 2025
Orthopedic Surgeon Robert Brooks, DO, Joins Froedtert & MCW Fond du Lac East Johnson Clinic - KFIZ News-Talk 1450 AM — Dec 3, 2025

Information sourced from the clinic's website as of July 11, 2026. Own this clinic? Claim or correct this listing.