Neurology in Garden City, NY - ProviderMatch

Neurology • Garden City, NY • +1 location locations

Home/Garden City/Neurology/Neurology in Garden City, NY - ProviderMatch

About

Book appointment Call clinic Visit website Get directions

Clinic Type

Neurology

Address

300 Garden City Plaza, Suite 312, Garden City, NY 11530

Phone

631-230-6644

Email

privacy@chsli.org

Opening Hours

Not published — contact the clinic to confirm hours.

Website

https://doctors.catholichealthli.org/specialty/Neurology/near/Garden%20City%2C%20NY?page=1

Services Offered

—

Team

Jennifer McMonigle, MD — MD

Insurance & Payment

—

Languages Spoken

—

Social Media

Twitter Youtube Facebook Linkedin Instagram

Photos

What Patients Say

Overall sentiment across review platforms: mixed

Healthgrades (Dr. Eva Sahay): 3.4/5 stars (8 reviews)
Birdeye (McMonigle Neurology Associates): 4.3/5 stars (40 reviews)

Patients praise

Friendly and caring medical or clinical staff (in some experiences)
Compassionate care approach (reported by some patients)
Clean or nice office environment
Effective resolution of medical issues for some patients

Common complaints

Rude and unhelpful front desk or administrative staff
Difficulty reaching the office via telephone
Appointment scheduling issues, including long waits or cancellations
Perceived lack of empathy or failure to listen to patient concerns

"Dislike receptionists- rude and uncaring. They like to make things difficult - cancels appointments and the reschedules months out, like I’m the problem."

— Healthgrades (Review of Dr. Eva Sahay)

"Communication & empathy is poor, staff is rude especially Skylar who is unprofessional. The only staff members that took time to be pleasant & professional were Gloria; Judy & technician-Luis."

— Birdeye (Review of McMonigle Neurology Associates)

"Coming here is like dealing with trusted family. Would not consider changing doctors. They always treat me with tender loving care."

— Healthgrades (Review of Dr. Eva Sahay)

Synthesized from public review platforms as of Jul 11, 2026 — sources: [1][2][3][4].