Fitchburg Podiatry

Podiatry • Fitchburg, WI

Home/Fitchburg/Podiatry/Fitchburg Podiatry

About

Fitchburg Podiatry is an independent, locally-owned foot and ankle clinic in Fitchburg, Wisconsin, located 15 minutes south of Madison's Capitol. The clinic, owned by board-certified podiatrist Dr. Mary Hickner, offers comprehensive foot and ankle care including exams, x-rays, custom orthotics, ingrown toenail procedures, diabetic wound care, and referrals to specialists. Telemedicine is available, and the clinic accepts insurance and private pay.

Book appointment Call clinic Visit website Get directions

Clinic Type

Podiatry

Address

2960 Triverton Pike Dr. Suite 107, Fitchburg, WI 53711

Phone

(608) 467-2141

Email

info@fitchburgpodiatry.com

Opening Hours

Monday 9:00 AM–1:00 PM CST; Tuesday 9:00 AM–4:00 PM CST; Wednesday Closed; Thursday 9:00 AM–4:00 PM CST; Friday 9:00 AM–1:00 PM CST; Saturday & Sunday Closed

Website

https://www.fitchburgpodiatryllc.com/

Telehealth

Telemedicine available

Services Offered

Foot and ankle care
New and established patient exams
Foot and ankle x-rays
Custom orthotics
Over-the-counter and prefabricated foot products
Ingrown toenail procedures
Diagnostic and therapeutic injections
Diabetic wound care
Wound debridements
Management of infections
Electronic prescriptions
Referrals to advanced imaging
Laboratory services
Referrals to other specialists

Technology & Equipment

Podiatry treatment technologies
Online scheduling
Healow patient portal
Electronic prescriptions
Imaging referrals

Team

Mary Hickner, DPM, Diplomate of the American Board of Podiatric Medicine; Certificate of Added Qualification in Podiatric Surgery; Fellow of the American College of Podiatric Medicine; Member of American Podiatric Medical Association; Member of Wisconsin Podiatric Medical Association — Board Certified Podiatrist; Owner and Founder

Insurance & Payment

Not accepting insurances at this time
Most insurance and private pay
Accept most insurance and private pay

Not accepting insurances at this time; accepts most insurance and private pay

Self-pay, Online scheduling, Patient portal (Healow), Electronic prescriptions, $40/per visit established, Most insurance and private pay

Languages Spoken

English

Pricing

$40 per visit (established)

FAQs

Board certification?

Board Certified by the American Board of Podiatric Medicine

What is the payment policy for insurances?

Not accepting insurances at this time.

What insurance options are accepted?

Accept most insurance and private pay.

What is the telemedicine policy?

Telemedicine is available; note that the provider may determine that you need to be seen in person for additional evaluation.

Commitments

Not explicitly stated as guarantees

Awards & Accreditations

Board Certified by the American Board of Podiatric Medicine

Photos

What Patients Say

Overall sentiment across review platforms: mixed

Birdeye (Armstrong Podiatry): 4.2/5 stars (39 reviews)
Healthgrades (Dr. Cataldo): 4.6/5 stars (7 reviews)
Healthgrades (Dr. Armstrong): 4.0/5 stars (8 reviews)

Patients praise

High patient satisfaction with Dr. Hickner's care at Fitchburg Podiatry LLC
Dr. Cataldo noted for kindness, compassion, and surgical success
Professional, expert care reported in many reviews
Helpful and encouraging staff experiences

Common complaints

Reports of unprofessional staff attitude
Issues with office environment and appointment scheduling difficulty
Some patients felt disrespected or that concerns were dismissed

"My left foot was very well taken care of by Dr.Hickner. Thank you! I recommend her 100%."

— Fitchburg Podiatry LLC website

"He is a very kind, compassionate and caring doctor, and spends as much time with you as you need. He deserves 5 stars."

— Healthgrades review of Dr. Cataldo

"Mr Armstrong stated he would not operate on my feet because of my age and the fact that I smoked. I have never been treated as badly as I was treated by this person."

— Healthgrades review of Dr. Armstrong

Synthesized from public review platforms as of Jul 11, 2026 — sources: [1][2][3][4].